Couple builds a mountain vacation home with attached 1000 sq ft cabin for the husband’s mom, and refuses his sister’s demands to use it like a free family resort

Advertisement
  • Older woman sitting with younger woman on outdoor chairs in a grassy yard in front of a cabin, with a dog running toward the camera.
  • My wife and I built a mountain vacation home in 2020 and have used it regularly since then.
  • Two years ago my elderly mother mentioned she'd like to have a cabin near me and we talked about buying one near us.
  • After viewing several homes, and realizing how expensive it would be to purchase, we decided to consider an ADU (attached dwelling unit) on our large lot.
  • It took us a year and half to design and build, a very nice 2 bedroom/1 bath 1,000 sq ft home.
  • Man in a yellow jacket standing on a snowy deck outside a wooden house, talking on a phone.
  • The deal was that my wife and I would allow it to built on our property, and we'd cover maintenace, all utilities, taxes and insurance, etc.
  • Ultimately it was an early inheritance transfer. Here is the rub and where I would appreciate feedback, and to help understand if AITAH.
  • I have a couple siblings, they've never visited, and weren't not close. They often rent homes in our area, but still never visit, even when we offered.
  • When they found out my mom was considering buying, they were excited, because in my opinion, they were getting access to a free vacation home, but ultimately were left disappointed when my mother decided to build on our property.
  • Recently I found out my least favorite sibling (and new boyfriend, and kid) has messaged my mom and stated, "they'd like to plan some inexpensive vacations and would like to use her new cabin." I have a problem with this because "her" cabin is on my property, and we share an extensive common use area and I don't want to start a trend of random family members thinking they can freely use grandmas cabin at their leisure.
  • The rules my mother and I established in the beginning was that family could visit IF they were visiting when she was present.
  • Essentially, if no grandma, no siblings, no nephews/nieces, etc. This has been communicated to everyone. My mother and I have discussed this and have aligned on general use rules when it comes to family use, but this one sibling continues to push.
  • My mother has now directed her to me, I'm planning to draw a hardline in the sand.
  • So AITAH? In my opinion, my mother and I have an arrangement, siblings. are not included, but they seam to think they have a say in who and how the home is used on my property.
  • Extra-Astronomer-688 Of course NTA.
  • glasshopper85 NTA. Your home is your peace and peace doesn't usually involve mooching siblings. You two have an agreement and I'd stick to my guns.
  • Fit-Discussion-4910 NTA. This is less about the cabin and more about entitlement. They showed no interest in visiting family until there was something to gain. The agreement was already defined and fair. Letting one person bend it opens the door for everyone else and then you lose control of your own property. Drawing a firm line now actually prevents bigger conflicts later.
  • Okra_Zestyclose NTA. It's literally a MIL suite; it's "her" place for living, not a guest house.
  • JefflnVancouver NTA as long as the property is still legally under you jurisdiction.
  • 11Turnips I think I see why she's your least favorite sibling. Nta. You and your mom agree. Mom is just tired of putting up with her and wants you to maintain that hard line in the sand. Do you have a good lock for it? So you don't find sis and crew have just shown up anyway? Sis needs to learn No means No.
  • logical-sanity NTA. Draw that line in the sand and make sure mom doesn't give any of them a key to the new abode.
  • Spinnerofyarn NTA. "Part of the agreement with Mom in allowing her to build on our property was that no guests are allowed if she's not there. We notified the whole family of this, and you were included. We know you have asked Mom and she has told you no. Now you're asking us to override that policy. The answer is no, just as it will always be no. I'm really bothered by how disrespectful you're being to her by not accepting her answer that we required as part of allowing her to have a cabin on o
  • Background-Ad3308 Family always wants to come knocking when they thin they got a free ride. NTA
  • tryintobgood You already answered your own question. No nana, no anyone else. Simple

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article